Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jorg's avatar

I spent perhaps too much, in one course or another, trying to explain that people typically balance 4 things when deciding where to live. And they almost always involv serious trade-offs.

The mnemonic is: Live, Work, Shop, Play. After deciding where, we may decide what to buy.

Where you live is your safe space. Where you sleep and keep you stuff. You're looking for Safety.

Work is your job, or perhaps the job you want to have. What are you doing to pay for the Safe place?

There immediately begins a trade-off. How close to work must your Safe place be? Since Roman times, the optimal trade between home and work has been 30 minutes travel. That also means supply/demand will make those Safe places the most expensive of your choices.

You can pay less by increasing or decreasing your travel time. Most people don't want to live too close to where they work, Many people will trade time/distance for a good Safe place at a much lower price.

Then there is Shop. Since you don't produce everything you consume, you must purchase it from a vendor. This was more important before the emergence of Amazon and more general home delivery. (The "shopping experience" nearly killed some New Urban developments because they didn't allow for adequate [to homeowners] shopping spaces. Even those who love the idea of New Urban seemed to not really want to schlep groceries, etc by walking a couple of miles.)

Shop now also makes living at a distance from cities (places that concentrate Live, Work, Shop, and Play), less burdensome, so perhaps travel time is not so relevant.

Play is whatever you do to fill leisure time. Watching professional games in person, musical venues, theater, eating out, ice skating, participatory sports, reading, watching TV, whatever.

In the past, Play opportunities tended to follow new, reasonably high-density housing. That is why upscale suburbs gained upscale dining choices, and everyone got a Subway sandwich shop. (The smallest town I know with a Subway has about 500 residents. In the middle of nowhere and attracts customers for at least a 12-15 mile radius.) And why you get nght time softball leagues, and ice rinks, and even malls (a shop/play hybrid).

Then I said, if you're buying a home, list 5 must haves and 5 may not haves and stick to them as closely as you can. Do NOT look at any lacking 2 must haves or having 2 must not haves.

That's a whole lot of balancing, but in the end tends to get more satisfactory results. Your price range will determine the other trade-offs to be considered.

Daniel A. Nagy's avatar

In my experience, real estate agents typically fall into one of two very distinct categories; those that want the maximum profit from the first deal with a new customer and those that understand that buying a house is such an immensely important decision in one's life that their client will remember for an eternity if someone made a good job helping them land a good deal and come back for more themselves or send their friends and family their way. With the latter type,

20 more comments...

Ready for more?