Are Children Giffen Goods: An Economic Puzzle
As a general rule, people buy less of something the more expensive it is: Demand curves slope down. But suppose you are spending most of your income on beans, the cheapest available food. The price of beans falls, freeing up some of the money you were spending on them. You can now afford an occasional hamburger, so you buy fewer beans. Beans in this hypothetical are a Giffen good, a good you buy less of when the price falls.
Someone invents an inexpensive and reliable way in which parents can choose the gender of their offspring. From the economic standpoint, this represents an increase in quality — you get a child of your preferred gender instead of a fifty-fifty chance — at no significant increase in cost. Increased quality at constant cost corresponds to decreased cost at constant quality; you are now getting more for your money. Lowering the cost of something increases the quantity demanded.
Do you conclude that, as a result of the new invention, the birth rate goes up? If not, why not? Are children Giffen goods?
A Misleading Quiz
(For economists)
1. Who invented the idea of Ricardian rents?
2. Who invented Marshallian quasi-rents?
3. Who originated the core idea of Nash Equilibrium?
4. Who invented Stigler’s Law?
5. Who first described Giffen Goods?
(For other people)
6. Where did Irish potatoes originate?
7. Where was the original Brazilwood tree found?
8. Where do Jerusalem artichokes come from? For extra credit, what kind of food plant are they a variety of?
9. What animal is the Canary Islands named for?
10. Which country makes Panama hats?
11. What is a camel’s hair brush made of?
Verse Contradictions
A very long time ago, a friend of the family named Dorothy Brady introduced us to the game of finding pairs of proverbs with opposite meanings, such as “He who hesitates is lost”/”Look before you leap.” More recently it occurred to me that one might do the same thing with pairs of poems, ideally both by the same poet. My one example so far — my wife thinks she pointed it out to me thirty or forty years ago — is a pair of sonnets by Millay.
Part of the argument of “Oh, think not I am faithful to a vow“ is summed up in the line “Were you not lovely I would leave you now.“
While the argument of “Love is not blind“ is
“Well I know
What is this beauty men are babbling of;
I only wonder why they prize it so.“
Can anyone offer other such pairs of poems?
My web page, with the full text of multiple books and articles and much else
Past posts, sorted by topic
A search bar for past posts and much of my other writing
A draft of my next book, Consequences of Climate Change, webbed for comments. Read it and tell me what I have wrong.

I recently saw someone post this pair of proverbs:
If at first you don’t succeed, try, try again.
Insanity is doing the same thing and expecting different results.
I can't pair poems but I can do what Dorothy Brady did: pair contradictory sayings.
Here's mine:
Too many cooks spoil the broth.
Many hands make light work.