Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Shasby's avatar

About a third of all high school students used to smoke. Nicotine has been shown to help with ADHD symptoms.

Dennis Hackethal's avatar

“…those so diagnosed are widely claimed to be unable to function in a classroom without medication.”

That, to me, is the crux of the issue. “Unable to function in a classroom” basically means: ‘unable to bend to their teacher’s will’. That’s not what a properly functioning mind does. It’s what a broken mind does.

Of course teachers will enroll doctors to drug kids to ‘help’ break their spirit.

To me, that quote reads as though someone had written about slaves in the 1850s: ‘…those diagnosed with drapetomania are widely claimed to be unable to function on the plantation without medication’. Drapetomania was a medical diagnosis at the time: slave life was viewed as so pleasant that only an insane person would want to flee. (I know it’s hard to believe but don’t take my word for it, look it up on Wikipedia.) Of course, there’s no such thing as a slave ‘functioning’ on the plantation. That’s a word only a slaveholder would use.

The first question any doctor should ask, in my opinion, before prescribing medication, is this is: **‘Is the patient free?’** If not, then free him first, and the need for medication may well go away.

59 more comments...

Ready for more?