Fun post! I was just reading a book about Wyatt Earp and the wild west (which I might be writing about on my own blog in a few weeks), and there was a very strong tradition of private vengeance there too, even though the law frowned on it.

It's also worth noting that the Jewish law about the Avenger of Blood, in the Torah, reads like it isn't establishing that system but rather taking a system that already existed and limiting it. From Numbers 35: "You shall select cities to be cities of refuge for you, that the manslayer who kills any person without intent may flee there. The cities shall be for you a refuge from the avenger, that the manslayer may not die until he stands before the congregation for judgment... Then the congregation shall judge between the manslayer and the avenger of blood, in accordance with these rules."

Expand full comment

Tribal, deeply mountainous areas of northern Albania and Kosova have long operated under a well-established and oral transmitted system of feud norms.

One British source living thereabouts for some time in the early XX century spoke of some areas seeing upward to a third of all adult men dying in revenge killings.

Expand full comment

Any idea how things are going on in US cities? Are the gangs developing norms, customs to provide restitution? Or is it still shoot-em-up and retaliation? Listening to the morning news out of Chicago, it seems the latter.

Expand full comment

<i> law is, must be, enforced by the state ...</i>


What of disagreements arising from a lack of the clear assignment of rights, and violations thereof?

If I recall correctly, there have been at least three small, armed, conflicts in various parts of the Americas each called "The Pig War", where settlers from the different cultures attempted to bring forward localized European expectations and found themselves in conflict over who should build the fence, carry the water, keep the pigs separate from the lettuce ...

If the rights and responsibilities are clearly assigned and widely recognized -- carved into Tablets of Stone, say -- such conflicts might be averted. Well, theoretically. More likely the capital-L "Law" gets carved into stone at the end of the war (by the winners) to avert the NEXT one. I expect, too, after a ruling government carves out such a Law that following generations of lawyers, scholars, disputants and clerks will wrangle about whether the Law about fencing the lettuce away from the pigs analogously applies to the Montagues' more-or-less wild rabbits pinching from the Capulets' patch of perennial primroses.

Expand full comment