Discussion about this post

User's avatar
JiSK's avatar

I once had the misfortune of having a physics teacher who considered reading the textbook adequate instruction in its contents. He assigned a chapter, then lectured solely on advanced topics that derived from the chapter's contents. After a few weeks of this (in a 102 class, mostly nonmajors), I showed up to his office hours to berate him on behalf of the large fraction of the class who were utterly lost. I think he, by the end of the quarter-hour, at least temporarily understood that he needed to teach the basics in his class about the basics. Who knows how long that stuck. And this was at a fairly elite *teaching* school, Reed College (professor likely now retired).

As they say of interviews and hiring processes, so too of classes: almost all the teachers students encounter are terrible, and so they will tend to learn habits which are best suited to terrible teaching. Validity of the converse - that most students you teach are terrible - may vary wildly by school.

When considering the 5% highlighters, consider that the textbook authors are frequently as bad as my physics professor; for much of the textbook , "what [...] the rest of the book is there for" has no sensible answer; it's to pad the page count, or indulge the author, if they even thought it through that much. C.F. Feynman's disgust at the entire slate of available elementary school textbooks, as written up in _What Do You Care What Other People Think?_.

Expand full comment
Doctor Mist's avatar

Back when I was teaching computer science (which “The Paper Chase” tells me is quite different from law) I invented an idea I quite liked. I didn’t teach long enough to have a big back-catalog of previous exams, so when I wrote an exam I just gave the students a *heavily* redacted copy of it a few days earlier. It was enough to show them the sorts of skills they would need to solve the problems, but not anything they would be able to do in advance and memorize.

I never heard if they found it helpful or irritating. :-)

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts